Big-ticket masterpieces set to test art market revival in New York auctions

The major New York auction houses will offer more than $1.4 billion in art next week, a total that specialists say could signal the first broad recovery in the high-end market after three consecutive years of declining sales.

Sotheby’s, Christie’s and Phillips plan a series of evening and day auctions that begin on Nov. 13. Aggregate estimates are roughly 50% higher than the same sales in 2023, according to market trackers, reflecting a surge in supply of so-called trophy works matched by renewed demand from wealthy collectors.

Demand catches up with supply

Sotheby’s Chief Executive Charles Stewart said buyer activity has remained robust throughout 2024, but consignors only recently started releasing headline pieces. “Our demand levels have been setting records,” he noted, citing record bidder registrations and consistently strong hammer prices versus pre-sale estimates. “In the last two months the supply has caught up.”

Improved sentiment follows stronger-than-expected auctions in Paris and London this autumn and coincides with lower U.S. interest-rate expectations and rising equity markets. The combination has created what several dealers describe as the most favorable climate in more than a year for owners considering a sale.

Estate collections dominate the week

The most valuable grouping comes from the estate of cosmetics heir Leonard Lauder. Sotheby’s will offer 55 works carrying a combined estimate above $400 million. Centerpieces include Gustav Klimt’s 1914 “Portrait of Elisabeth Lederer,” guided at more than $150 million, and two Klimt landscapes estimated at over $70 million and $80 million, respectively. The Lauder trove also features six bronze sculptures by Henri Matisse and an “Midsummer Night” canvas by Edvard Munch.

A second estate, that of real-estate figures Jay and Cindy Pritzker, contributes 37 works expected to bring more than $120 million. A Vincent van Gogh still life is priced in excess of $40 million.

Christie’s lineup includes Claude Monet’s water-lily painting “Nymphéas,” David Hockney’s double portrait “Christopher Isherwood and Don Bachardy,” and Mark Rothko’s “No. 31 (Yellow Stripe).” Each carries an estimate between $40 million and $60 million, with the Rothko guided above $50 million.

Market bifurcation persists

While auction houses are optimistic, recent data underline a split between the very top of the market and lower price tiers. Sales of works priced above $10 million fell 44% in the first half of 2025 compared with the same period a year earlier and are down 72% from the post-pandemic peak in 2022, according to the Bank of America Private Bank “Art Market Update”. No single lot exceeded $50 million at auction during the first six months of this year, versus 13 in the comparable 2022 interval.

By contrast, dealers reporting annual turnover below $250,000 logged a 17% increase in 2024, while galleries transacting above $10 million posted a 9% decline. Specialists attribute the divergence to demographic shifts: older buyers who once chased household-name artists are tapering activity, whereas younger collectors favor emerging creators and lower price points.

Imagem: Internet

New headquarters draws crowds

Sotheby’s expects its recently opened global headquarters in Manhattan’s Breuer Building to amplify momentum. The Brutalist landmark on Madison Avenue attracted more than 10,000 visitors during its first week of public exhibitions, according to the company. Stewart said consignors were motivated by the added visibility that the space offers.

The gold toilet returns

In addition to paintings, Sotheby’s will present one of the art world’s most talked-about contemporary objects: Maurizio Cattelan’s solid-gold toilet titled “America.” Crafted from roughly 100 kilograms of 18-karat gold, the functional sculpture sparked headlines when it was shown at New York’s Guggenheim Museum in 2016 and later stolen from England’s Blenheim Palace. Sotheby’s has not published an estimate, but the metal alone is worth about $13 million at current prices. The work comes from a private U.S. collection.

Some advisers view the piece as a cultural flashpoint rather than a barometer of serious collecting, yet its inclusion exemplifies the marketing power auction houses wield during marquee sales weeks.

Test for a fragile recovery

Despite the upbeat forecasts, analysts caution that a single week of auctions will not resolve broader questions about long-term demand at the summit of the market. Shifting tastes, succession planning among aging collectors and competition from primary-market venues continue to shape buying habits.

Even so, dealers say the caliber of works on offer means solid sell-through rates could help re-establish confidence. “You do not need decades of connoisseurship to grasp the appeal of the Klimts,” one longtime adviser remarked.

Whether the upcoming sales mark a temporary uptick or the start of sustained growth, next week’s results will provide the clearest data yet on how swiftly high-value art can rebound.

Crédito da imagem: CNBC / Crystal Lau